Welcome to Puckerbrush Pizza LLC, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of Payne, Ohio. Located at 117 E Merrin St, our establishment has quickly become a beloved staple among locals and newcomers alike. With the warm touch of a small-town family business and a menu that tantalizes taste buds, Puckerbrush Pizza is where comfort food comes alive.

At Puckerbrush Pizza, we pride ourselves on serving not just pizza but an array of dishes that cater to every palate. From our signature pizzas to the renowned turkey club—a creation some patrons have declared as their absolute favorite—each bite is crafted with care and quality. Our review from Jenna Roberts perfectly encapsulates this sentiment, highlighting the joy of discovering such a standout eatery after moving from a bustling city.

The sense of community here is palpable, and many guests like Mark Folsom consider us a hidden gem. Our daily lunch specials are designed to offer variety, and we pride ourselves on seasonal dishes, like hearty soups in the colder months and refreshing salads during the warmer seasons. Each plate is a testament to our dedication to fresh, local ingredients and chef creativity.

What truly sets Puckerbrush apart is not just the food but the people behind it. With heartfelt service, as noted by Bryce Pollick, our team goes above and beyond to ensure every dining experience is remarkable. The friendly faces greet you like family, creating an atmosphere that makes you want to linger and savor every moment. Even during challenging times, such as winter storms, our commitment to offering fresh, quality meals does not falter, as shared by Misty Zizelman.

Whether you’re a long-time local or just passing through, a visit to Puckerbrush Pizza LLC promises great food and warm smiles. Our reputation as the best food within a 30-mile radius has garnered attention, and we invite everyone to see for themselves what the excitement is all about. Join us for a meal that encapsulates the essence of what it means to eat well in a small town.